IND vs BAN 1st Test Playing XIs: Rohit Sharma loses toss, picks three seamers as Axar Patel, Kuldeep Yadav find no place in pace-friendly conditions
Abhishek Nayar defends decision to send Shivam Dube at 4, Shreyas Iyer at 6 and KL Rahul at 7, says 'When it doesn't work out, these questions...'
IND vs SL 2nd ODI: On a spin-friendly track, India's middle-order crumbled under pressure as Jeffrey Vandersay ran riot with a six-wicket haul.
In last few years, India had a no.4 conundrum in ODIs. India had tried several options over the years but they didn’t work. But keeping Shreyas Iyer at no.4 and KL Rahul at no.5 provided stability to the team. However, under the new regime with head coach Gautam Gambhir and his support staff taking over, keeping the left-right combination has become almost a necessity as it seemed in the second ODI against Sri Lanka. There was no set batting order. Shivam Dube who batted lower down the order in first ODI was promoted to no.4 and Iyer, Rahul were pushed down the order.
As India collapsed and lost the match by 32 runs, questions have been raised about the need to keep left and right combination. However, assistant coach Abhishek Nayar has defended the decision to shuffle the batting order which was done to counter the variety of spinners.
"My belief is that in any sport, position only matters if you're playing in different areas of a game. We lost wickets in the middle phase, and that's where the middle order batters batted. It's not as if middle order batters batted towards the end,” Nayar said in the post-match presentation as quoted by ESPNCricinfo.
"If you look at numbers like four, five, or six, maybe sometimes it can play games in your head. It was more about keeping a left-and-right combination, keeping in mind that there were offspinners, and a legspinner in the Sri Lanka team.
"The thought process was right. When it doesn't work out, these questions are asked often. But I've always believed that if a middle order batter bats as a middle order batter, it is the right decision."
Shuffle leads to collapse
Sending Dube did not work in India's favour. He was dismissed lbw for a four-ball duck by Jeffrey Vandersay. Batting out of position, Iyer and Rahul contributed to the collapse as well. Iyer got out lbw whereas Rahul dragged the ball on to his stumps. Both the batters lost their wickets to Vandersay.
Iyer, Rahul’s batting position in 1st ODI
Earlier, in the first ODI, Washington Sundar batted at no.4 instead of Dube. He could not make a difference and departed for a single-digit score. Iyer and Rahul batted at no.5 and no.6 scoring 23 and 31 respectively.
MORE ON SPORTS TAK:
Popular Posts
Former Pakistan cricketer wants R Ashwin to respond to Nathan Lyon's 'stupid statement' and say 'India will defeat Australia 5-0'
From Denmark to Australia, Mohammad Nabi creates history by becoming first player to win against 46 different teams as Afghanistan bamboozles South Africa
IND vs BAN 1st Test LIVE streaming: When and where to watch 1st Test between India and Bangladesh
AFG vs SA 1st ODI: Historic moment for Afghanistan, beat South Africa for first time in cricket
Kamindu Mendis surpasses Sunil Gavaskar and equals Pakistan sensation with century against New Zealand
SL vs NZ 1st Test: Kamindu Mendis' century helps Sri Lanka post 302/7 at Stumps Day 1
'Retirement has become a joke..players from other countries': Rohit Sharma takes indirect dig at Pakistan players
Gautam Gambhir reveals Virat Kohli chanted 'Om Namah Shivay' before facing every delivery from pacers during 2014-15 tour of Australia
'Way forward and was truly..': Ricky Ponting reacts to becoming Punjab Kings' new head coach ahead of IPL 2025